Relative efficacy of 32P and 89Sr in palliation in skeletal metastases.

32p and 89Sr have been shown to produce significant pain relief in patients with skeletal metastases from advanced cancer. Clinically significant pancytopenia has not been reported in doses up to 12 mCi (444 MBq) of either radionuclide. To date, no reports comparing the relative efficacy and toxicity of the two radionuclides in comparable patient populations have been available. Although a cure has not been reported, both treatments have achieved substantial pain relief. However, several studies have used semiquantitative measures such as "slight," "fair," "partial" and "dramatic" responses, which lend themselves to subjective bias. This report examines the responses to treatment with 32P or 89Sr by attempting a quantification of pain relief and quality of life using the patients as their own controls and compares toxicity in terms of hematological parameters. METHODS: Thirty-one patients with skeletal metastases were treated for pain relief with either 32P (16 patients) or 89Sr (15 patients). Inclusion criteria were pain from bone scan-positive sites above a subjective score of 5 of 10 despite analgesic therapy with narcotic or non-narcotic medication, limitation of movement related to the performance of routine daily activity and a predicted life expectancy of at least 4 mo. The patients had not had chemotherapy or radiotherapy during the previous 6 wk and had normal serum creatinine, white cell and platelet counts. 32P was given orally as a 12 mCi dose, and 89Sr was given intravenously as a 4 mCi (148 MBq) dose. The patients were monitored for 4 mo. RESULTS: Complete absence of pain was seen in 7 of 16 patients who were given 32P and in 7 of 15 patients who were given 89Sr. Pain scores fell by at least 50% of the pretreatment score in 14 of 16 patients who were given 32P and 14 of 15 patients who were given 89Sr. Mean duration of pain relief was 9.6 wk with 32P and 10 wk with 89Sr. Analgesic scores fell along with the drop in pain scores. A fall in total white cell, absolute granulocyte and platelet counts occurred in all patients. Subnormal values of white cells and platelets were seen in 5 and 7 patients, respectively, with 32P, and in 0 and 4 patients, respectively, after 89Sr therapy. The decrease in platelet count (but not absolute granulocyte count) was statistically significant when 32P patients were compared with 89Sr patients. However, in no instance did the fall in blood counts require treatment. Absolute granulocyte counts did not fall below 1000 in any patient. There was no significant difference between the two treatments in terms of either efficacy or toxicity. CONCLUSION: No justification has been found in this study for the recommendation of 89Sr over the considerably less expensive oral 32P for the palliation of skeletal pain from metastases of advanced cancer.

Combined fluphenazine and lidocaine for pain relief in head and neck cancers.

A successful method of treating intractable neoplastic pain in 12 cases is discussed. A completely new method was tried combining long-acting phenothiazine and lidocaine to achieve long-lasting pain relief. This combination gave pain relief which lasted for weeks. A possible explanation of the mechanism is offered.

Radiographic clinical and functional diagnosis and treatment of low back pain associated with pelvic malposition

Low back pain ist frequently associated with malposition of the pelvis due to an imbalance of the postural muscles. In these patients functional malposition of both the sacrum and the ileum can be observed, resulting in differences in the length of the legs. We investigated whether the return to a normal position correlated with pain relief. METHODS: A total of 40 control patients and 65 patients with low back pain were included in this retrospective study. Prior to the start and at the end of the treatment period the differences in the length of the legs were determined manually and radiographically at the ankles with the patient in the supine and sitting position. Furthermore, somatic dysfunctions at C0/C1 or C2/C3 were determined in all patients. In the low back pain group, 39 patients were treated with manual therapy at the cervico-occipital joints and/or infiltration of the iliosacral joint with local anaesthetics and 26 patients were treated with parenteral non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). The success of the treatment was determined after 6 months and correlated with a return to the normal pelvic position. RESULTS: Somatic dysfunction at C0/C1 or C2/C3 and differences in the length of the legs were observed in 32 control patients and in all patients with low back pain. Manual therapy/lidocaine infiltration resulted in complete long-term pain relief in 23 patients (59 %), while in the NSAID group only 4 patients (15 %) became pain free (P < 0.05). Long-term pain relief significantly correlated with normalization of the pelvic position. CONCLUSION: Differences in the length of the legs can be successfully treated by manual therapy at C0/C1 or C2/C3 in the majority of patients with pelvic malposition. However, infiltration of the iliosacral joints is often required as additional therapy for short-term and long-term pain relief. Treatment with NSAIDs alone is only seldom effective in cases of pelvic malposition and rarely affords long-term pain relief.

Temporary external pedicular fixation versus definitive bony fusion: a prospective comparative study on pain relief and function.

Temporary external pedicular fixation is used as a prognostic instrument when treating degenerative conditions with spinal fusion. We studied the validity of the method and whether a functional test could improve the prognostic value of such fixation. Twenty-six patients with long-standing lumbar pain had an external temporary fixation. Pain levels were registered before fixation on a visual analogue scale at rest, as a mean for the previous week, and at seven different standardized activities. Walking capacity and walking speed for a standardized distance were also measured. Identical evaluations were then repeated during the external fixation and 1 year after definitive fusion. Based on the outcome of the temporary fixation, 20 patients were recommended for definitive surgical fusion. In six cases, the option of fusion surgery was rejected due to an unfavourable pain response or insufficient pain relief during the test fixation period, and this group was not further followed within the study. One year after surgery, 14 of 20 patients reported a good outcome. Solid bony fusion assessed by conventional radiography was seen in 19 patients. One patient with a poor clinical outcome had a pseudarthrosis. The mean values for pain level at rest, during last week and at the seven different activities in the functional test tended to decrease after fusion compared to the situation with temporary external fixation. In no activity did the external fixator overestimate the mean positive pain-relieving effect after definitive fusion. The walking capacity significantly increased, while the walking speed did not alter at the three different measurements. We conclude that with a good outcome ratio of 14 patients out of 19 having a solid fusion, the external frame improved patient selection and can be used as a valid prognostic instrument. The pain relief and function after definitive fusion can not be quantified by the external fixation, probably due to the fact that the stabilisation with an external frame is partial. The value of the functional test design presented is moderate, and an outcome evaluation comprising pain relief at rest and mean pain level during a week in fixation seems adequate.

Development of cancer pain relief and palliative care in the Philippines.

The article describes the development and progress of cancer pain relief and palliative care in the Philippines from 1986 onwards. The strategy employed was a stepwise progression that began with the establishment of government policy, followed by measures to improve availability and accessibility to oral morphine, and finally, continuing nationwide professional education. Key elements to successful implementation were the presence of a national cancer control programme; the active participation of the World Health Organization, the Department of Health, the Philippine College of Surgeons, and the Philippine Cancer Society Inc; and research development and utilisation. Data from three clinical studies are also presented, which showed the efficacy of the WHO Method of Cancer pain relief among samples of Philippine patients, and that cancer pain relief alone did not significantly improve overall quality of life, demonstrating the need for comprehensive palliative care.

Continuous intrathecal morphine treatment for chronic pain of nonmalignant etiology: long-term benefits and efficacy.

BACKGROUND: To analyze, prospectively, the long-term effects of continuous intrathecal morphine infusion therapy in 16 patients with chronic nonmalignant pain syndromes.METHODS: Twenty-five patients with severe, chronic, nonmalignant pain that had proven refractory to conservative management were considered candidates for trial of intrathecal spinal morphine. Sixteen patients achieved more than 50% pain relief after a trial period of intrathecal morphine infusion. They were implanted with fully implantable and programmable pumps through which morphine was delivered intrathecally on a continuous basis. These patients were followed prospectively and underwent careful evaluation of their functional and mental status, and pain intensity measurements using standardized techniques before treatment and every 6 months thereafter in the follow-up period. The follow-up period ranged from 13 months to 49 months (mean 29.14 months +/- 12.44 months) for the patients who had implanted morphine pumps.RESULTS: The mean morphine dosage initially administered was 1.11 mg/day (range 0.2--6.5 mg/day); after 6 months, it was 3.1 mg/day (range 0.4--8.75 mg/day). In long-term observation, no patient had a constant dosage history. The patients who received intrathecal morphine for longer than 2 years all showed an increase in morphine dosage to more than 10 mg/day. The best long-term results were seen with deafferentation pain and mixed pain, with 75% and 61% pain reduction (visual analog scale), respectively. Nociceptive pain patients had best pain relief initially (78% pain reduction) but it tended to decrease over the follow-up period to 57% pain reduction at final follow-up. The average pain reduction for all groups after 6 months was 67.5% and at last follow-up, it was 57.5%. Ten patients were satisfied with the delivery system and eleven reported improvement in their quality of life. In two patients, morphine was not able to adequately control the pain without producing undesirable side effects requiring the addition of clonidine to their infusion medication. In this series, 12 patients were considered successes and 4 patients were considered failures. In two patients, the intrathecal opioid therapy was unable to produce satisfactory pain relief and in the other two patients the pumps had to be explanted because of intolerable side effects.CONCLUSIONS: In our experience, the administration of intrathecal opioid medications for nonmalignant pain is justified in carefully selected patients.

Pain and the ethics of pain management.

KIE: After clarifying the concepts of "pain", "suffering", "pain of body", and "pain of soul", the author presents a humanistic ethic of pain management based on the premise that the patient has a strong "prima facie" right to freedom from unnecessary pain. This premise imposes two moral obligations upon medical professionals: (1) the duty not to inflict unnecessary pain and suffering upon the patient, and (2) the duty to do whatever is possible to alleviate pain and suffering. Both the questions of informed consent to treatment of pain and the right to refuse pain relief are addressed.

Comparisons of pain relief mechanisms between needling to the muscle, static magnetic field, external qigong and needling to the acupuncture point.

pain relief mechanisms of needling to the pain-producing muscle, application of a static magnetic field or external qigong, and needling to the acupuncture point were investigated in an experimentally designed pain producing muscle of animals. Single isometric twitch height in situ was reduced gradually by 10 Hz tetanic stimulation for one hour of the gastrocnemius muscle of guinea pigs. This reduction of twitch height was recovered by injection of 0.3-1 ml saline to the artery of this muscle, or of injection of a vasodilator, isoproterenol dissolved in 0.1 ml saline. Hence, reduction of twitch height could be induced by reduction of circulation in the muscle and recovery of it could be induced be recovery of circulation. Since it is easily considered that a pain substance might be accumulated in a muscle under reduced circulation, and such an accumulated substance might be eliminated by recovery of circulation, the reduction of twitch height after tetanic stimulation could be estimated as the pain-producing muscle and recovery of twitch, as the pain relieving muscle. 1) Needling to the pain muscle, 2) application of a static magnetic field or external qigong to the muscle, and 3) needling to the acupuncture point recovered the reduced twitch height due to tetanic stimulation. Atropine abolished this effect induced by the above 1, 2 and 3 procedures. Hence, the cholinergic vasodilator nerve might be involved in the induction of this effect. A sciatic nerve cut did not influence the effect of 1), but abolished the effect of 3). Denervation and capsaicin abolished the effect of 1). Substance P and a calcitonin gene- related peptide (CGRP) recovered the reduced twitch height, and atropine blocked the effect of CGRP, but did not block that of substance P. The effect of 2) was equivalent to that of anticholinesterase. A rostral lesion of the contralateral anterior hypothalamus did not abolish the effect of 3, but a caudal lesion of this region did. Electrical stimulation of this region produced an effect similar to that of 3). From these results, it was concluded that muscle pain relief by these procedures might be induced by recovery of circulation due to the enhanced release of acetylcholine as a result of activation of the cholinergic vasodilator nerve endings innervated to the muscle artery. However, manners of activation of the cholinergic nerve was different in effects of 1), 2) and 3). 1) might be induced by axon reflex of the CGRP nerve, 2) might be induced by inhibition of cholinesterase and 3) might be induced by a somato-autonomic reflex. The reflex center of this might be in the anterior hypothalamus.

Ductal drainage or resection for chronic pancreatitis.

We report a 10 year review comparing the results of pain relief after three procedures for chronic pancreatitis: Whipple pancreatoduodenectomy, modified Puestow side-to-side longitudinal pancreaticojejunostomy and distal pancreatic resection. Results of follow-up review at 6 months, 2 years and 5 years were tabulated. Five year follow-up data were available on more than 80 percent of patients. The proportion of good results for pain relief decreased with the passage of time regardless of the procedure performed. Although equally good results are obtained after either pancreatoduodenectomy or pancreaticojejunosotomy, we conclude that in the presence of a dilated duct, the procedure of choice is pancreaticojejunostomy. If the duct is not dilated, we then favor pancreatoduodenectomy, after which the pain relief is significantly better (p = 0.05) than after distal resection. Our data show that, for all factors evaluated, the poorest pain relief was obtained after distal resection. Therefore that procedure has limited value when used specifically for relief of pain in chronic pancreatitis, except in the uncommon circumstance when the disease is confined to the distal part of the gland. Our study also shows that patients who have more radical distal resection have no better pain relief than those who have 50 percent distal resection.

Clinical and physiologic evaluation of stellate ganglion blockade for complex regional pain syndrome type I.

OBJECTIVE: The efficacy of peripheral sympathetic interruption after stellate ganglion blockade was assessed by a sympathetic function test. Results were compared with clinical signs such as temperature changes, pain reduction, and the development of Horner syndrome to evaluate the correlation with clinical investigations. DESIGN: Stellate ganglion blockade with local anesthetics was carried out via an anterior paratracheal approach in 33 patients suffering from complex regional pain syndrome type I. Patients were examined before and after the procedure. For assessment of sympathetic nervous function, the vasoconstrictor response to sympathetic stimuli was assessed using laser Doppler flowmetry. Clinical parameters like surface temperature changes (thermography), pain relief (visual analogue scale), and Horner syndrome were monitored. RESULTS: Twenty-three (70%) of 33 patients developed an increase in temperature difference between the treated hand and the contralateral hand of more than 1.5 degreesC after the procedure, which is a clinical sign of sympathicolysis. In 48% (n = 11) of these patients, the sympathetic function test showed an undisturbed sympathetic nervous function. In 10 patients, no significant increase in temperature difference was observed. Although these patients presented with a normal sympathetic vasoconstrictor response, 4 felt pain relief of more than 50%, suggesting a placebo effect. Only 7 patients with pain relief revealed both clinical sympathicolysis and extinguished sympathetic nervous function and qualified for sympathetically maintained pain. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical investigation is not reliable in the assessment of stellate ganglion blockade. Proof of sympathetically maintained pain based on pain relief after stellate ganglion blockade is not conclusive.